ALL OF YOU WHO READ ME KNOW MY FEELINGS ABOUT GREG PAPA REPLACING TED ROBINSON as 49ers radio play-by-play broadcaster.
I thought Robinson was blindsided.
He even said so.
This much is certain: the mystery continues --even after a year and a half removed from the transaction, which shocked the Bay Area Sports world and beyond, the entire machinations over the Papa hiring still lingers.
What really took place? What exactly went down? How many egos and friendships are still torn apart and forever compromised.
Now comes more information and exclusive content you want and deserve reading 415 Media and I hopefully deliver.
To be a hundred percent up front --not in any way an indication that I've been anything but--I'm still torn by this story. It involves having to navigate between two very good people; people I have known for some time; we're not great friends but friendly enough and more than just acquaintances.
I pursued this story and wanted the facts. The truth is something unique. It aces out falsities and rumors. It's a sensitive story but one that deserves clarity and total reality.
49ers' director of broadcasting, Bob Sargent, a former KNBR higher-up and veteran management guy and Bay Area native, wanted to go in another direction. He hired Robinson and both were friends and allies --but Sargent was a big Greg Papa fan. He marveled at Papa's style and personality and got to know him well --a true fan.
When Papa was let go by the Raiders, namely by owner, Mark Davis, Sargent was on a mission: somehow, someway, get Papa to the 49ers' perch in the radio broadcast booth. It would involve a series of personal moves and professional complications, a certifiable RISK with a capital "R", but one that Sargent chose to confront, even if it meant the possibility of a termination of friendship and bond with his friend, Robinson.
Sargent wanted to get Papa on board. He didn't pursue him as much as hunt him down. There would be roadblocks and tons of issues, some of which seemed to spell doom and gloom. It not only would hit Robinson, but Sarge as well. Robinson was well-liked, respected, admired by not only the team brass, but by the Faithful, the 49ers' fans, the Bay Area sports landscape. Sargent knew all that and then some but became adamant that it was time to move forward and begin his pursuit.
It wasn't an indictment of Robinson, as I learned first hand through examining this story as I did--it was more Sargent wanting Papa once he became a free agent. Sargent thought of Papa as the sports broadcast equivalent of Michael Jordan, with less complications --he loved Papa's passion and NFL football adulation and thought it would translate well in the radio booth. If he didn't move forward with his quest, a mission fraught with all kinds of potential chaos, Sargent thought, then he'd be doing himself and the organization a disservice, it was a moment of truth.
So Sargent made contact with Papa and thus the courtship began in earnest and was officially on a roadmap. As complex as it would take and close, the courtship was amazingly lucid in nature: what was supposed to be an hour-long coffee between Sarge and Papa turned into an almost eight-hour marathon. The transaction was closed. Well, sort of.
Here's what transpired: Sargent was committed. Although it would be months before anything was official, six months, to be exact, the deal was still in place if not the total structure. Many landmines still existed and were to be handled. Nothing was set in stone. A myriad of issues were yet to be determined. It was far from a done deal.
Bottom line: This was a YUGE seal and loads of stuff was on the table.
The financials were not worked out. The last-minute details and issues were to be eradicated and handled. They were, but the hard part was just beginning. Finalizing anything as complicated as this involved lots of work and energy.
Done.
Papa was on board. Robinson, who was just a few weeks earlier, given a two-year contract extension, was to be informed of the decision and close out the 2018-'19 season. It would be a shock, surely, but Sargent made sure that Robinson would receive all the money owed on his contract and that hopefully, Robinson would agree to be involved in the 49ers organization as a sort of good-will ambassador, a community liaison,. That position was left open --surely, Robinson would need time and plenty of thought process to consider such a role, given his dismissal and sudden departure. It was only normal.
Sargent's move would be both his personal and professional mark, good and bad. Maybe more great and awful: it would cause havoc and most certainly risk his own (Sargent) demise and consternation from the team's ownership and brain trust. Again, Ted Robinson was a popular and well-respected individual within the franchise hierarchy, from team president, Al Guido to principle owner, Jed York. Like York, Robinson, was a Notre Dame alum and Robinson admirer. Guido and York signed off on the deal. The Papa pursuit was done.
The '19-20 season began in Tampa with a new PBP man in place; Papa and analyst, Tim Ryan, working the game with vigor and energy. The 49ers beat an overmatched Tampa Bay team and a week later, the Bengals on the road. Papa began in earnest a signature touchdown call that I kind of hated but soon caught on and began to get traction
The 49ers steamrolled the NFL with an unbelievable 13-3 season and trip to the playoffs and Super Bowl in Miami. They lost in painful fashion to the KC Chiefs but a storied franchise was back on the radar.
Sargent's pursuit and personal goal was nearly a mission accomplished. It will be one still massively looked at and gazed upon. I'm still wondering. But I gotta give Sargent credit: man, this guy has brass you-know-what.
And then some.
Rich,
ReplyDeleteAre you saying that Guido and York had no push back on this decision and it was Sargant decision to make ? This move baffles me, I would think they would lose more listener's then gain with Pappa taking over the play by play from Robinson.
Guido and York had to OK it, yes Neal. They could have very well nixed it, leaving Sargent against it, both from 49ers ownership and Robinson himself. It was an extraordinary gamble.
DeleteAh, the little-known comedy duo Guido and York who were unceremoniously tarred and feathered in 1840 near Billings, Montana. Several decades later their descendants would be jokers of another sort, but equally deserving of being tarred and feathered.
ReplyDeletePapa's a smarmy East Coast prick. Ted Robinson got shafted.
ReplyDeleteNext, do Darya's hooters.
ReplyDeleteYou missed an important note.
ReplyDeleteTim Ryan hates Greg Pappa but tolerates him professionally.
Greg Pappa is the one who vied for this job.
Did it all behind Ted Robinson's back. But this is expected from a Rat like Pappa.
How Sargent's determination plays out will depend on how the 49er Faithful feel as this contract continues. If most of the Faithful warm up and are okay with this, then it was the right move. If not, no matter how much NFL teams ignore their fans, Sargent will never hear the end of it from the Faithful if they end up being insulted at the Papa-Jordan comparison. Wasn't Sargent at KNBR when the Razor Ralph Barbieri replaced Dave Newhouse in a similar personality makeover? Sounds all too similar.
ReplyDeleteSo....Sargent hired BOTH Barbieri AND Papa? I guess he has
Deletea rolodex with low character jackasses.....
TOUCHDOWNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNNN SANNNNNNNNN FRANNNNNNNNCISCOOOOOOOOOOO
ReplyDeletePlease tell me what the numbers are of people listening on the radio or watching on tv. I'm a tv guy so I have no clue as to the abilities of the radio broadcast.
ReplyDeletePerhaps I'm biased, I loved Papa with the Raiders, but the Niners are somehow now unlistenable.
ReplyDeleteI cannot stand Greg. I cannot and will not call him by his stage name. His call last longer then some plays for the TD. He is still and will always be a Raider.
ReplyDeleteWhat is his stage name? And what is the real name?
DeleteSargent, York, Guido know something fans fail to understand: It doesn't matter which professional announcer is in the booth. Niners fans listen for the NIners, not the announcers. All fans want in the end are pros who know what they are doing. They'll get over their personal preferences (or tolerate whoever's on) because in the end they want to hear the game (when they can't watch it).
ReplyDeleteAs a big Warrior fan, I can't stand their local TV Broadcasts with the two clowns. Sound is always off, when watching the Warriors. I am so happy when their games are National.
DeleteWith Greg Papa, he mentioned when he used to be on with Bonta during that time, that he wanted to go back to the NFL and call NFL games, after essentially a year off when the Raiders let him go. The Niners had a good thing with Ted Robinson sure, but Greg Papa was a free agent, he was calling some college football games, and he was already kind of working with the Niners doing their pre and postgame on NBC Sports Bay Area. It made sense for the Niners to go after him, despite his Raider ties and him being more known in NFL circles for his work with the Raiders.
ReplyDeleteWill it always be kind of shady how this went down? I guess yeah, but if you're an NFL team and you have a chance to bring in a guy like Greg Papa to call games for your NFL team, you have to jump on that opportunity, or at least inquire about it. The Niners did have the edge in that Greg Papa didn't move anywhere to look for other NFL gigs and he was getting more familiar with covering the Niners more full-time on NBC Sports Bay Area and even on 95.7, after being all Raiders during his time as the Raiders radio play-by-play guy. Like he sometimes mentions, he switched teams. LOL.... He basically did the same thing years ago when he went from the A's to the Giants. That was kind of a different thing but he was all A's at that time, and then became a Giants guy.
On a side note, what a great 1st season with Greg Papa calling games for the Niners? It sucked it ended in a Super Bowl loss, but I'm sure even Greg Papa wouldn't have imagined a season like this for the Niners when he originally got the Niners gig.