Don't assume everything.
First off, in my early days of writing this blog, I ripped Liz Cook quite a bit. I know many people dislike her because her dad happens to hold a prominent job in the industry--which may have landed her a gig, OK, that happens but has ZERO to do with her anchor style.
I said she's not "great" but very few are here and elsewhere. It's the state of the business in this always-changing news environment. Every second counts now.
Cook is pleasant; is very good at reading her copy; has a nice demeanor and crisp delivery. She's not Cecilia Vega but those are rarities --Dion Lim over at KGO still drives me crazy but she's trying to lighten up and look original. Might be better to sound original but that's another story.
Another thing about Cook I like it that she does steady tosses. She doesn't pretend to be someone she isn't; in other words, she knows she's not Diane Sawyer but she's also not Darya Folsom either.
The other night I was watching Ken Wayne and shouting (again) "C'mon Ken, show a little emotion!" I forgot the story but it was not a 20-second throwaway; it demanded some sort of reaction. Not a phony look of sadness just maybe a simple nod --I got neither. This didn't alter my opinion of Wayne; I used to think he was always pretty good, underrated. Now I'm hot and cold with Wayne --more cold lately but overall he's still capable.
I'm pretty consistent with people I like but I change my mind. I've been all over the place with Frank Somerville --his anchoring is solid but I DESPISED his social media postings because I thought they were fake and self-serving --he knows it; I told him so directly but this is a new environment in the news business --most stations, including FOX, demand their on-air people to establish a social media presence --Somerville still annoys me with his Facebook shtick but it's part of his gig, they (management) demand it. Furthermore, on the air, he reads well and in a two-way camera shot asks legitimate questions for the most part. Plus, he's got multi-decade work at one station on his resume so he's doing some right.
Raj Mathai used to drive me crazy. I never, ever thought of him as a newsman let alone ordinary sports anchor but having watched him now for a good length of time, not only like him more, but respect him more. He's bright, focused, intelligent, asks cogent questions and reads his copy well which is 99% of the job. It isn't Mathai's fault that he has pretty boy looks and the females love him. Gees, I wonder why? (wink, wink)
I never warmed to Kristen Sze until very recently when she's been working with Dan Ashley. I watched more and saw, clearly, there was more to Sze than I had earlier figured. She's hard-working, you hear around---she's very legit reading the teleprompter and she's got a real, genuine personality contrary to some at 900 Front who think she's a stiff and a difficult one at that. I used "stiff"; her enemies used "bitch. Wrong on both fronts, Sze just does her gig and moves forward. In any event I actually like her quite a bit now which was not the case not so long ago.
YOU ASSUME I love Pam Moore. You assume wrong. Moore is better than average but not that great. I never thought she was awesome; I always knew she was legit and good, very good in fact but something changed. Maybe as KRON tanked and slithered into the abyss, it affected Moore. Maybe not, either way Moore is above average and that's about it.
I love Carolyn Tyler and the beautiful simplicity of her anchoring on Sunday Morning on KGO. She is not spectacular, she's just good and profoundly sincere and professional. It's a rare sight to watch someone deliver the news without a bunch of noise and faux cackles --go figure.
READERS of 415 MEDIA:
415 MEDIA is the Bay Area's only independent media site and relies solely on donations, subscriptions, and contributions. PLEASE help keep this blog sustainable by making a contribution or becoming a PAID SUBSCRIBER ($25 one year/$30: two years); (any amount helps)-- It's fast and easy: simply go to the Pay Pal "Donate" icon on the right side of the blog and click on it. It takes but a minute and it's safe, secure and completely confidential. I will personally e-mail and/or call you thanking you for your support.
Cook, Moore and Tyler. Meh
ReplyDeleteDo you see that expectation where Media personalities are ordered to maintain a Social Media presence changing anytime soon?
ReplyDeleteI have to wonder how effective those perfunctory journals are with the younger demographics. The Media talent may also be hesitant to say anything in Social Media, lest somebody decide they just got 'offended' about something minor.
As I recall, Barbara Simpson did not like such demands either.
That stubborness may have lead to her dismissal.
Last Remark; Any chance in some other KGO talker coming on the scene to reduce the time Ethan is on the air? I hope for someone who is expressive and dynamic, but not rabid in a partisan sense.
God, I miss Barbara Simpson. Last real host they had on KGO with a solid show, even though I did not completely agree with her politics. Smart, interesting, didn't take any bull. Of course that's part of what got her canned, and it's digusting.
DeleteI don't understand who they're trying to attract with this constant push to social media. I hate watching the news and they give you some little teaser of a headline and say "go to our website to read the full story." I don't wanna go to your website, just give me the damn news here! That's what you're here for! I'm a relatively young viewer/listener for AM radio and network news.
Isn't Pam 4th best according to the orchards of San Jose?
ReplyDeleteI used to work with Frank Somerville. He really is the way he comes across. I'm no right-wing Fox-watching conservative, but Frank is a little too mamby-pamby for me, with his holier-than-thou sanctimoniousness and his refusal to see anything but shining goodness in people with any brown in their skin. But then, he is a Berkeley boy, I believe...
ReplyDeleteI really despise the soft sighs after every sad story. Same with Julie Haener.
DeleteAnd, Dan Ashley does the same thing. Oh, really! You read that stuff night after night, year after year, and you still have to "emote." Please, we all know it's fooey! You aspire to some sort of Hollywood cameo! Drop the act. We're on to you. We're not buying it. Just deliver the news! I certainly don't envy any one of you. Miserable business from what I've read here, backstabbing, gossipy, cutthroat, and phony.
DeleteWHOA! Rich, you got me started. Have you ever watched Liz unscripted? Working her tiny brain as hard as she can, she still stumbles/fumbles on those ladies' shows. I don't give a fat fart how she got the job. I do think she's inept, uncomfortable and a simpleton.
ReplyDeleteDaddy's lil' girl.
DeleteJohn Oliver used a Ken Bastida (with a much fuller head of hair) clip on this show this week, where his delivery made it sound like Dana King was the murder victim in the lead story. Mildly amusing.
ReplyDeleteThe Sinclair Broadcasting bit was downright scary.
Caroline Tyler. Her voice. UGHHH. It drives me nuts.
ReplyDeleteDiane Dwyer. Oh how I miss her.
ReplyDelete