Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Comcast SportsNet Bay Area Part of Cable Conglomerate That Runs Bay Area TV Sports: The Good, The Bad, And The Ugly

Let us today go about the business of elaborating on the function of one Comcast SportsNet Bay Area.


This is the one of the gazillions of Comcast affiliates around the country that has amassed a fortune in the brand of building around local sports teams and their ancillary, highly-lucrative revenue streams.


In short, a mini ESPN empire with a vast Pacific Ocean-size pool of empty pockets replete with cash and ready to spend.


There's nothing onerous here to report other than the fact that unlike ESPN-- which although has a built-in financial connection with many of its clients like the NFL and NBA, at least tries to perform basic journalistic pursuits even if it involves the integrity or denigrates the brand. We need only look at the excesses of various Athlete getting in trouble, obscure or non-obscure coach behaving badly, team owners outside of the NBA seemingly bent on hiring mostly white-male, non-African-American coaches. ESPN isn't perfect by any stretch of the imagination but they're good at faking it. And truth be told they're so big and Disney-infected you could argue that they have a legitimate reason why truth-telling and hard-nosed investigative sports journalism is not their biggest virtue.


Comcast and its sports tentacles, on the other hand, don't pretend to want to rock the boat. Don't mess with the franchises that butter your bread and bring food home to cook and place big cars and trucks in your garage. That part of their sports template has always been in the rear-view mirror. This isn't exactly groundbreaking material but it's worth noting because that element of the operation is never so readily apparent here in the Bay Area.


CSNBA blankets the professional sports apparatus; its clients include the SF Giants, Oakland A's and San Jose Sharks. It has highlight show and packages with both the SF 49ers and Oakland Raiders. Because its corporate owner, Comcast, owns NBC, it is allowed to have multiple tie-ins and show highlight packages involving the NFL.  Conglomerate it is. And controversy is not a wanted element to their content.


With CSNBA, it's the programming, stupid! And that's just fine and dandy but you can't have it both ways. You can't profess to be utmost objective in the local sporting life, particularly when you own a sliver of the Giants as CSNBA does. You can't be serious in making the case for your highly-publicized "Insiders", who essentially act as public relations liaisons for their respective team and beat. Question: When's the last time any of CSNBA's insiders broke any story of relevance outside of some in-house, between the lines/chalkboard, trade minutiae? The answer is never. Again, nothing sinister there other than CSNBA would have you believe they look to lead the light and break new ground in their sports coverage. Bullshit.


When CSNBA debuted in April, 2009, they took the Bay Area sports scene by storm. They leased big studios in tony South-of-Market office buildings. Built a gigantic newsroom and threw a lot of dough for droves of HD's, computer banks, fiber-optic gear and of course, pricey talent. Greg Papa was their first big local hire and soon after they brought in other highly-paid anchors, reporters, writers, editors, even news directors and producers. Papa's salary alone was slightly north of the $250K range.


Beyond providing their bread and butter content--Giants/A's/Sharks/College Football/Basketball games, CSNBA didn't stop there. They built state-of-the-art studios to televise their version of SportsCenter, "Comcast SportsNet Central", a highlight-induced program with accent on the video and short on personality. That was their intent. They went further.


They developed and created a daily sports show: "Chronicle Live", now Yahoo Sports Talk Live: (Full Disclosure): I have guested on the show and make my own booking requests on behalf of my blog, 415 Media.


The problem with the show then and to this day is that its participants say little or offer nothing even remotely controversial. That's not an opinion, it's a fact. And there's ample evidence to indicate that anything slightly negative conveyed by a reporter, a radio guy, whoever, involving CSNBA's local sporting interests would be met with swift disapproval from, say, the Larry Baer company. Nothing overt, mind you, but just enough to make sure that it was in the best interest of CSNBA not to disrupt the positive PR flow, again, not to rock the boat--bad for business. I asked earlier, has any of the Insiders actually broke any significant stories--I now ask you when's the last time any Yahoo panelist said something, anything!, of substance that moved the needle? This is not meant to belittle, to humiliate, to begrudge, to be mean and petty, it is merely provided to suggest that CSNBA wants it both ways; it seeks to create something bold and invigorating yet it really is nothing more than beige visual wallpaper with a few loud talking-heads who say essentially nothing.


Proof positive was during the Damon Bruce moronic anti-women sports rant, frequent guest, Ann Killion, the sports writer from the Chronicle, curiously said nothing about the Bruce affair. (Other than a few innocuous tweets) Coincidentally, Killion, was also a frequent guest on Bruce's KNBR talk show. To its credit, CSNBA did shows on the Bruce brainfart but again, nothing of substance, nothing that gets picked up by other media affiliates appeared. Not surprising.


What CSNBA does, mainly, to be fair, it does well. Some of its analysts are fairly good and informed and offer interesting, if not enlightening, material. And to be fair, since most of these talking heads are ex-jocks, they have to be careful. For every Vida Blue there's Rich Aurilia, (yawn) and Shawn Estes, (double yawn); On football, Dennis Brown, an ex-49er is a delightful surprise. Bill Romanowski says quite a lot but some of it gets obliterated by his overly-verbal tenacity. (Figure it out).


CSNBA has no doubt, for the most part, become a welcome addition to the Bay Area Sports electronic/cable/Internet domain. It has top-tier production values; its telecasts are mostly first-rate with a great residue of professionalism and expertise procured by GM, Ted Griggs, a widely-respected broadcast head. We just wish they'd be a tad more apt in the real-world sports arena and provide at least a spoon-size spread of humility.




That's not asking too much, is it?


*Follow me on Twitter


Tips/E-Mail: Rich.Lieberman@Gmail.com


Please keep 415 Media sustainable: Donate via the PayPal icon on the top right of the blog.







17 comments:

  1. One of the owners of Comcast Sports Bay Area is Baseball Partners LLP. That is the LLP of the giants owners, so there you go. They own the vehicle that has automatic content for most nights, and all the "talent" on air are just the party hosts.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Rich, You blogged a bit after the Damon Bruce rant that it was "very telling" that his shows were no longer archived. Thought you might have noticed that is no longer the case as all his recent shows now appear on the KNBR website archives..

    ReplyDelete
  3. I can't believe I come to your page today and no discussion of what went on at KSFO today during Savage's first hour? I just went to the KSFO560.com 7 Day Archive and it's still up. Go 1:25 seconds into the first hour at Noon, and you'll hear it. This went over the air!!!!!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Uh, I actually heard it if your're talking about the dead air and Savage talking not knowing he was on the air with a hot mic...he didn't say anything crazy.

      Delete
    2. You really are a Homer, Rich.
      I heard it too. Embarrassing. What a delusional jackass.

      Delete
    3. @10:54....same idiots as usual feeling better about themselves by ripping other people.

      Delete
    4. I find that Savage bashing another host on KSFO and championing himself to be somewhat interesting. Par for the course, I know, but if Ronnnnnnn Owens did it we'd never hear the end of it. Fact.

      Delete
  4. Anyone who has worked at Comcast knows what an egotiscial a-hole Chris Oliver is. He brow beats his workers there because he can since they're mostly young and being paid peanuts, and he acts as if he knows what the hell is going on in local sports when he doesn't have a clue. He likes to sit in his office and send out annoying e mails, constantly bother people who are working by incessantly phoning them, or he'll go to their desks and harass them. How he's lasted this long is one of the great mysteries, but look at some of the other jerks in management who have survived for years at places such as KRON, KNBR, KTVU and many of the other broadcast outlets in the bay area, and it's really no surprise.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I think Oliveres' frustration and angst is driven by the fact that even the former NCAA female gymnasts who work there as script runners all tower over him.

      Delete
  5. The hail and hearty Henry Woford on Comcast Sports doesn;t seem to do a lot of sports reporting or analysis. Mainly he seems to chuckle with the news anchors.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Only Jaymee Sire has moved up the food chain. Other questionable on-camera hires have come and gone - Matt Morrison, Damon Andrews, John Henry Smith. The "Feldy-Fareed" mess is too painful to watch. At least they are not at the bottom of the 'annoying pool' like Henry Woford and Erin Coscarelli

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Dave Benz also..The T-wolves PBP. I cant figure how mumbles got hired for a job where speaking clearly is required. But,Dave has made a career of doing that so far.

      Delete
    2. Stan is a sell-proclaimed Bay Area media member. Ummm. Not so much. He criticizes a broadcaster who mumbles and doesn’t communicate effectively yet defends his own broken syntax, fractured writing skills and disjointed thoughts as “Stanbonics”. He will claim, “I was right so it doesn’t matter how poorly my ‘post’ was written.” Then he will name-call.

      Delete
    3. I actually like Ahmed Fareed. I don't care much for Feldy.

      Delete
  7. I haven't turned on CSN for content other than the actual Giant's game (not the pre and post game shows) in approximately 2 to 3 years. I checked it out in the beginning but soon noticed there's nothing the hosts have to offer to me that is worth sticking around for. I can hear all of their talking points on KNBR, I don't need to hear them regurgitated five different ways from five different hosts. I will say Ann Killion was VERY easy on the eyes. She is a beautiful woman. Also, I enjoyed Ray Ratto when he was on there.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The problem with Comcast sports net, is that they're a huge corporation run back in Philly, and they do everything with all of their affiliates nation-wide in a 'cookie-cutter' style. No imagination, and that's why a clone and stooge like Oliver was hired to begin with. They also pick kids just out of school and pay them peanuts and make them work their butts off. The 'talent' which they hire comes and goes at an alarming rate. What did Jayme Sire do that was every worth anything, except appear as Rich likes to put it: "Easy on the eyes."

    ReplyDelete