I'VE OFTEN SAID THIS and it bears repeating --the garish "ad-libbing" --more like unnecessary chatter that the anchors at KTVU are forced to utter, between themselves and a reporter doing a live shot, is AWFUL.
First off, the questions are inane and dumb for the most part and really do more damage than good and screw up the story. I suppose KTVU management is looking for some sort of technique only the technique here is awkward -looking and only muddies up what the viewer can see as obviously disingenuous. Even the most veteran KTVU staffer agrees--"it sucks; it is dreadful."
I agree.
Look, it's one thing to ask legitimate questions; a crime scene: Anchor to Reporter: "Do the police have a description of the suspect(s)?", for example. Absolutely warranted and called for but asking "duh" questions and looking at the teleprompter with a blank stare destroys whatever credibility KTVU anchors have in the first place. Heather Holmes is the worst offender. Julie Haener, sorry to say, is bad too but Alyana Gomez takes first prize. She's dreadful.
Making matters worse are the reporters in the field some of whom are incapable of answering questions--ad-libbing--on screen. They look ridiculous for the most part and KTVU's newscast in turn goes to hell right off the top. Rita Williams is shaking her head. Dennis Richmond would probably scream off mike.
Hey guys? Do yourselves and the viewers a favor: Can the BS ad-libs. They seriously suck. And guess what? I know a lot of KTVU anchors and they would say the same, off the record, but I know they hate it just as much as I do, trust me.
Claudine Wong is by far the worst ad libber I have ever seen.
ReplyDeleteHey Rich....its not about news anymore.
ReplyDeleteWhat the heck is wrong with Pam Cook? It is obvious management does not "groom" her to be a Fox female. She's a little overweight and she could use a wardrobe makeover. Her delivery has become tired...too many uhs and ahs during her report and she always has a weird smile on her face. I think she needs a vaycay. Maybe Fox feels if they tuck her away in the early morning no one will notice.
ReplyDeleteThis is what happens when you allow green reporters to script their own questions in live shots.
ReplyDeleteI remember when it was considered shameful to have scripted questions in a live report.
Most seasoned reporters didn't need scripted questions because they had some brains...and were ready for just about any question because they actually did the homework.
The was one anchor who nobody ever trusted with any live remote interaction...or questions....ever.
George Reading.
The best "spontaneous" anchor questions are followed by the "ad libbed" reporter response complete with a pre-made full screen graphic.
ReplyDeleteI find the ad libs after the evening weather report to be almost painful to watch. Bill Martin is especially guilty but so are the two anchors who are likely forced to play along with him. Just give us the weather, that's why you are there.
ReplyDeleteThat blue dress Heather always wear on TV is pretty R-Rated. Look closely on HD and you will see some exposure since Rich brought up that picture as an example.
ReplyDeleteWith a new 9PM News and exclusive interviews with Pelosi, KRON is Now the best LOCAL News in Bay Area..... Best Solar Eclipse Coverage....New LOCAL Team Sports Weekend Programs! 8-11P News Ratings Beating Everyone!!!
ReplyDeleteI kinda like the suburban soccer mom look of Pam Cook. Not mad.
ReplyDelete